Name: Pan-Seared Butter Basted Steak Recipe
Prep time: 10 min
Cook time: 10 min
Total time: 20 min
Ingredients: 2 x 600 grams bone in or 2 x 500 grams bone- out good quality aged rib eye steak; Estimate 250 grams per person of actual steak; Salt & Pepper; Olive oil for frying; 50 gramsKerrygold salted butter; 1 – 2 garlic clovespeeled and bruised (but whole); 1 sprig fresh rosemary; 2 sprigs fresh thyme; 80 gramsKerrygold salted butter; 1 1/2 tspfinely chopped parsley; 1/2 tspchopped fresh thyme; 2 tspcaperschopped; 2 anchovies; 1/4 tspDijon mustard; 1/4 tspgarlic powder; A few drops of Worcestershire sauce; 1/2 tspfresh lemon juice

Jump to Recipe Save it for later

I make a lot of steaks at home, and this method is the one I return to when I want something reliably luxurious without a lot of fuss. The combination of a quick, high-heat sear followed by gentle butter basting gives you an even brown crust and a silky, flavored finish. The café de Paris butter is the showstopper — salty, tangy and herb-forward — and it melts into the meat as it rests.

This recipe is practical for a dinner where the steak is the star. It asks for time at room temperature and a hot pan, then uses two stages of butter so you get both flavor-stuffed compound butter and an aromatic basting butter. Follow the steps in order and you’ll avoid common mistakes like overcooking or burning the butter.

Below you’ll find a clean ingredient checklist, exact step-by-step instructions, useful swaps (kept to the ingredients listed), the tools I reach for, and troubleshooting tips. Read once, cook once — and remember to let the meat rest.

Ingredient Checklist

Ingredients

2x 600 grams bone in or 2 x 500 grams bone-out good quality aged rib eye steak — pick bone-in for more presence and flavor, bone-out if you prefer easier carving; estimate 250 grams of actual steak per person.
Salt & Pepper — simple seasoning to build the crust; season liberally and evenly.
Olive oil for frying — coats the pan and raises the sear temperature without smoking immediately.
50 grams Kerrygold salted butter — for the pan-basting stage; provides a rich finish and carries aromatics.
1–2 garlic cloves (peeled and bruised but whole) — infuse the butter; bruised cloves release flavor without burning quickly.
1 sprig fresh rosemary — aromatic woody note for the basting butter.
2 sprigs fresh thyme — pairs with rosemary and carries through the butter bath.
80 grams Kerrygold salted butter — for the café de Paris compound butter; cools and adds a flavored finishing dollop.
1 ½ tsp finely chopped parsley — bright herb in the café de Paris butter.
½ tsp chopped fresh thyme — more herb lift for the compound butter.
2 tsp capers (chopped) — bring briny, piquant bites to the compound butter.
2 anchovies — umami backbone in the café de Paris butter; mash into the butter for even distribution.
¼ tsp Dijon mustard — adds subtle sharpness to the compound butter.
¼ tsp garlic powder — rounds the garlic note without adding texture.
A few drops of Worcestershire sauce — a savory accent that deepens flavor.
½ tsp fresh lemon juice — brightens and balances the richness of the butter.

Pan-Seared Butter Basted Steak in Steps

Make the café de Paris butter: let 80 grams Kerrygold salted butter soften at room temperature, then add 1 ½ tsp finely chopped parsley, ½ tsp chopped fresh thyme, 2 tsp capers (chopped), 2 anchovies (finely chopped), ¼ tsp Dijon mustard, ¼ tsp garlic powder, a few drops of Worcestershire sauce and ½ tsp fresh lemon juice. Mash everything together in a small bowl until the anchovies are broken up and the mixture is well combined. Shape into a log or a spoonable dollop and refrigerate briefly if you want it firmer.
Season the steaks on both sides with salt & pepper. Let them rest at room temperature for 1–2 hours (depending how warm your kitchen is) so they come up toward room temperature.
Preheat a heavy skillet (cast iron recommended) over high heat. Add enough olive oil to coat the pan and heat until the oil is shimmering.
Sear the steaks: place the steaks in the hot pan and sear the fat edge first (to render it), then sear each flat side. Flip the steaks a few times while searing so they develop an even, deep brown crust on all surfaces.
When the steaks are nearly at your desired doneness, remove them from the pan and set aside. Wipe the pan clean with paper towels to remove excess oil and any blackened bits.
Return the wiped pan to medium heat and add 50 grams Kerrygold salted butter, the 1–2 garlic cloves (peeled and bruised but left whole), 1 sprig fresh rosemary and 2 sprigs fresh thyme. Allow the butter to melt and bubble gently so it infuses with the herbs and garlic without burning.
Put the steaks back into the pan. Tilt the pan and spoon the melted herb butter over the steaks repeatedly, flipping and basting both sides until the steaks finish cooking to your preferred doneness.
Remove the steaks from the pan and let them rest on a cutting board for at least 10 minutes.
Slice the rested steaks, arrange on a platter, and add slices or dollops of the café de Paris butter on top. If the café de Paris butter is too firm, warm it briefly with a blow torch or a short burst in the microwave until softened, then spoon or drizzle it over the meat.

Why This Recipe Belongs in Your Rotation

This approach hits the essential marks of a great steak dinner: a crisp, evenly browned exterior, and a deeply flavored interior. The initial high-heat sear builds the crust; the separate butter basting stage prevents the butter from burning while still delivering that nutty, golden butter flavor. The café de Paris compound butter adds layers of acidity, brine and herb that elevate every bite.

It’s also adaptable. You can scale the steaks, make the compound butter ahead, and execute the sear and basting in about 20 minutes once everything is at room temperature. The method teaches you how to manage heat and fat so you’ll get consistent results whether you’re cooking for two or four.

Easy Ingredient Swaps

Bone-in or bone-out rib eye — use either option from the ingredient list depending on how you prefer to serve and carve.
1–2 garlic cloves — use 1 if you want a subtler garlic note; use 2 for more aromatic basting.
Café de Paris assembly — if you prefer a softer dollop, let the 80 grams Kerrygold salted butter soften a bit longer before mixing, or chill it briefly to set into a firm log for prettier slices.

Equipment & Tools

Cast iron or a heavy skillet is essential for a dependable sear. You’ll also want a pair of tongs for flipping, a spatula to hold the steak if needed, a spoon for basting, a small bowl and fork for the compound butter, and paper towels to wipe the pan between sear and baste. A thermometer (instant-read) is optional but helpful for precise doneness.

Pitfalls & How to Prevent Them

Burned butter: don’t introduce the butter to full-high heat. Reduce to medium for the basting stage so the butter melts and infuses without blackening. If you smell smoke or see dark bits early, remove the pan briefly, wipe, and start again at a gentler heat.

Cold steak: searing a cold steak traps residual chill inside and lengthens cook time, which risks overcooking. Let the steaks come up toward room temperature for the recommended 1–2 hours.

Uneven crust: flipping once or twice is fine, but don’t move the steak constantly on initial sear. Let a surface crust form before you flip; then flip a few times to build an even crust on all sides.

Spring to Winter: Ideas

Spring: serve with a simple salad of peppery greens, shaved fennel and a lemony vinaigrette to cut through the richness.

Summer: pair with charred corn, grilled asparagus or a tomato and basil salad — bright summer vegetables balance the heavy butter flavors.

Autumn: roasted root vegetables and a mustardy green (like mustard greens or sautéed kale) stand up to the steak’s richness.

Winter: creamy mashed potatoes or a gratin and braised greens make the meal cozy and substantial.

Pro Tips & Notes

Timing and temperature

Room temperature steaks sear more evenly. Use the pan hot enough to shimmer the oil but not so much that the butter smokes. If you like a thermometer, target about 50–52°C (122–125°F) for rare, 55–57°C (131–135°F) for medium-rare, 60–63°C (140–145°F) for medium — remember the steak will rise a few degrees while resting.

Butter handling

Make the café de Paris butter first so it has time to meld. If you’re short on time, soften the 80 grams butter in a warm bowl for a few minutes so it’s easy to mix. After shaping, refrigerate briefly if you want clean slices to place on the steak.

Slicing

Rest the steak at least 10 minutes so juices redistribute. Slice against the grain for the most tender bite. Arrange slices, then top with the café de Paris butter so it melts over the meat.

Storing, Freezing & Reheating

Store leftover sliced steak in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 2–3 days. If you’ve got café de Paris butter left, it keeps well wrapped in the fridge for several days; you can also freeze it in a log wrapped tightly for up to 1 month.

To reheat steak gently, warm in a low oven (about 120–130°C / 250–265°F) until heated through, then give it a quick pan sear for 30–45 seconds a side in a hot skillet with a small knob of the 50 grams butter to refresh the crust. Avoid microwaving if you can; it dries the meat. If you must microwave, do short bursts and finish with a hot pan.

Your Questions, Answered

Can I skip the café de Paris butter? Yes, but it’s worth trying at least once — it transforms the final taste. If you really don’t want to make it, finishing with slices of the 50 grams Kerrygold salted butter will still give you great flavor.

What if my butter burns while basting? Wipe the pan, lower the heat, add a fresh small knob of butter, and continue. High heat plus butter equals a fast burn; give the butter time on medium to infuse.

How do I know doneness without a thermometer? Press the steak with your finger: soft and squishy is rare, slightly springy is medium-rare, and firm is medium or above. This takes a bit of practice, so consider an instant-read thermometer for confidence.

See You at the Table

This pan-seared, butter-basted approach turns a simple rib eye into a meal that feels thoughtful and celebratory without being complicated. Make the café de Paris butter first, respect the heat on the pan, baste with patience, and rest the steak properly — those are the three habits that make this recipe sing.

When you try it, slice a piece, let the compound butter melt on top, and taste. It’s rich, herb-forward, and properly balanced by lemon and caper brightness. Share a photo if you like; nothing makes me happier than seeing someone else nail a great steak at home. See you at the table.

Print Recipe Pin Recipe